Dear Scotts:  Just Try, One Time, Not to be So Shitty.

Dear Scotts: Just Try, One Time, Not to be So Shitty.

Spread the love

Trademark image from Shutterstock

Does anyone remember when we posted about the “You Can Grow That!” campaign started by garden writer C.L. Fornari? Her perfectly nice, well-intentioned idea was to start a social media campaign to encourage non-gardeners to garden, or to encourage all of us to grow new or different plants, or–well, there are a lot of different ways the phrase could be interpreted, but you get the idea.  A slogan that garden writers, nursery and hort industry people, and others could use to promote gardening.

That’s all good, right?

So she came up with the idea, got feedback, registered the domain, sent out press releases, and generally encouraged people to use it.  Bloggers were doing “You Can Grow That!” posts once a month, and so on.

She got lots of publicity for it, including this December 8, 2011 article in Garden Center magazine.

Then guess what happened? The very next day, on December 9, 2011, Scotts applied for a trademark application for the phrase “You Can Gro That.”

Get it?  Gro?  Like that blue stuff they make?

Yeah.

Here is their trademark application.  And by March, they had put their trademark to use by taking out an ad in Costco’s magazine.

All of this was unknown to C.L., who did not get around to trying to trademark her idea until July.  I’m surprised she got around to it at all–after all, there’s no money involved.  It was just a nice idea aimed at getting people to join together in a spirit of gardening goodness to encourage more people to join in.

Once she realized what had happened, there wasn’t much she could do.  As she explained in a blog post yesterday, she talked to a lawyer and the advice was to give it up.  Scotts will out-lawyer her all day long.   No use fighting it.

So she gave it up.  Gave up the whole idea of a website (she’d bought the URL), the campaign, whatever.

Because it’s more important that Scotts have another slogan (that C.L. thought of) to help sell blue chemicals, and Scotts has the money and the lawyers, so that’s where it ends.

Except it doesn’t have to.  Scotts could decide to stop being so shitty.  They could, right now, reach out to the very people they should care the most about–committed, impassioned, enthusiastic gardeners who talk of little else all damn day (and I should know, because I follow these people on Facebook and good lord, it is all they talk about.)  They could find someone down there at the chemical plant who is still in touch with some tiny scrap of humanity deep within their soul, and they could hand that person a piece of paper and and ask them to write a letter.

Here is what that letter needs to say.  This is the only thing it should say,

Dear Ms. Fornari,

I work here at the Scotts chemical plant, and let me tell you, this is a BIG organization.  REALLY big.  I mean, I’m just here in the Blue Division,  where we spray the blue stuff on the chemicals because we heard that ladies like pretty colors, and even in the Blue Division I don’t know the names of half the people I see every day.  We long ago gave up on having individual birthday celebrations, and now we just have a big blue sheet case delivered once a month, along with a printout of everybody who has a birthday this month.  That’s how big we are.

(blue factory via Shutterstock)

But I digress.  The reason I’m writing is because I just found out that one of our lawyers, a nice enough guy, really, except that sometimes he just tries too hard–anyway, this young man (it’s always the men who do these things, isn’t it?)–this young man read about your catchy slogan in one of the industry publications he is required under the terms of his contract of employment to read every day (and you thought spraying the blue on the chemicals was a crappy job!  He has to read–well, never mind) — anyway, the point is that this ambitious young man read about your slogan and got all fired up and filled out a trademark application THAT VERY DAY, and next thing you know, it’s the new slogan for our blue stuff.

But now it has come to our attention, here in the Blue Division and elsewhere in the company, that this was never our slogan to begin with!  It was yours! That young lawyer saw and opportunity and he took it.  And that’s where I come in.

You see, I am the co-chair of a new program at Scotts called We Don’t Have To Be Quite So Shitty All The Time. I am tasked with coming up with new, innovative, exciting ways for us to be just a little less shitty once in a while.  And when one of my spies in the legal division (we have to have a LOT of spies in Legal, as you can imagine) alerted me to this situation, I knew it was time to put WDHTBQSSATT into action.  It’s been several months since we last came up with a way to be less shitty, so we are really overdue at this point.

So.  As of right now, we are withdrawing our trademark for “You Can Gro That” and asking–no, imploring, beseeching, begging–you to take it up again (with the missing W, of course) and do as  you like with it.  Run a social media campaign to get more people gardening–honestly, that benefits us too, and I don’ t know why that young man in Legal didn’t think of that–or don’t.  It’s not up to us to decide.

It is only up to us to, once in a while, be a little less shitty. Now that I’ve done my duty for the day, I need to get back to my station.  Those chemicals aren’t going to turn blue by themselves!

Yours truly,

Louise Baker

Department of WDHTBQSSATT

 

Posted by

Garden Rant
on September 5, 2012 at 4:36 am, in the category Ministry of Controversy, Uncategorized.

19 Comments
    • Timeless Environments
    • 1st January 1970

    It’s incredible how these so-called science-based companies operate. What is even more incredible is that an actual science works for them. In this day and age of the New Age Religion of Scientism (* See Scientism Footnote by PBS.org), people need to question just what kind of science is being carried out. There are countless great papers revealing the truth about how our natural world actually functions and operates. As yet there is very little Biomimicry attempting to replicate these findings. Proof of this is just looking at who is in charge of Consumerism Products shoved down the average global citizen’s throat.

    • James Golden
    • 4th October 1981

    When was it? Two, three, four years ago, even longer, that I began to notice I couldn’t find bagged dirt at the big box stores? No. Only different kinds of “soil” or “planting medium” with Scotts Blue Stuff already in them. So much for overland runoff of chemicals and nutrients into our streams and rivers, even when we don’t want the chemicals. This is selling a product by stealth, and by subterfuge. Scotts, products for the ignorant gardener. “We know what’s best for you. Don’t worry your little mind. Buy Scotts. Buy Scotts. Buy Scotts.”

    • Lorraine Roberts from Plant Paradise Country Gardens
    • 12th February 2010

    Gardeners unite. Stop buying Scotts products. I would like to know who is still buying Scotts products and why?

    • Kaviani
    • 7th October 2013

    Agreed. I nearly slapped my partner for bringing home Scotts bird seed from Big Lots, no doubt part of their toxic batch quickly shuffled off to Seconds stores once they realized they could get sued for selling it. It was promptly tossed out after much fuss and evidence presentation (thanks, Garden Rant).

    • admin
    • 25th October 2013

    you need a t-shirt and bumper sticker spreading that message!

    • Laura Bell
    • 4th February 2014

    I’d buy ’em ! For me & for all my garden- & food-loving friends !

    • Nan Ingraham
    • 11th March 2014

    Amen C.L. I too enjoyed the blue factory image, I can see the factory workers running around drinking in the “Blue Juice”… after all isn’t it safe??? Thanks to Louise for standing up the Blue Meanies! You ladies Rock!

    • Sandra Knauf
    • 20th January 2017

    That was shitty. It’s a shitty company, obviously. I never buy their . . . (well I don’t want to get too redundant!).

    • Christopher C NC
    • 9th June 2017

    Just another example that for large swaths of the corporate world profit has become the supreme moral principle from which all and only good can flow. Nothing else but profit is to be considered when making decisions. That divine good out weighs all other concerns.

    • Mary Palmer Dargan
    • 13th August 2017

    My eyes are wide open. I’m trademarking my brand right now. CL and garden rant, my hat is off to you. I’ll wear a blue circle with a slash on a button to garden writers in Tucson.

    • TatteredSpinner
    • 1st September 2017

    Brilliant.

    • admin
    • 1st September 2017

    This makes me blue.

    • gemma
    • 2nd September 2017

    Louise’s letter reminds me of the Yes Men. Their last documentary was largely about their adventures after the website they created for the “Ethics Division” of Dow Chemical got them an invitation to appear on tv in Europe on the 20th anniversary of the Bhopal disaster as Dow spokespeople. The headlines read “Dow Does the Right Thing” until actual Dow spokespeople noticed the story and swiftly responded, no, we will not pay the medical expenses of the people permanently harmed, and no, we do not accept full responsibility.

    • admin
    • 5th September 2017

    Sad state of affairs I’m totally up with the “I don’t do Blue” slogan

    • Catherine
    • 6th September 2017

    If Corporations are People then Big Corporations are Psychopaths. Remember that in the voting booth!

    • Elsa
    • 6th September 2017

    Looking forward to a new catchphrase. I will miss the old one, it was really great. Call to action, empowering and all that, but I have complete faith a new one will be equally awesome. I think if Scott’s actually stopped being so shitty, I’d fall down in a dead faint! 😉

    • TatteredSpinner
    • 10th September 2017

    I’m not sure I understand, though, is that a real letter from someone actually working for Scotts? Or maybe the humor is just too subtle for me…

    • Chad B
    • 10th September 2017

    If there really were such a thing as the WDHTBQSSATT, it would be good for them to have a slogan of their own. Something that they could all rally around, get behind, and drive their mission.

    • Pat
    • 10th September 2017

    Scott’s blue is driven by green – as in $. So, adopting “I don’t do Blue” — and backing it up with purchasing decisions might make an impact.

Leave a comment

Recent Posts

The Wrong Way to Teach Eco-Friendly Gardening

I recently attended a “Green Yards and Gardens” talk in my town. The intern giving the talk was more knowledgeable than I expected, but the topics covered were no surprise: natives, invasives, ...

Read More

Learning to say goodbye—with pleasure

These hydrangeas, lilies, phlox, and so on used to be raspberry bushes. Death is  part of life, but this  fact is accepted with difficulty and nowhere more so than among gardeners. Perennials ...

Read More